---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Neighbours Speak Up <neighboursspeakup(a)gmail.com>
Date: Tue, Jun 1, 2021 at 1:53 PM
Subject: Fwd: Affordable Housing Commission Presents Recommendations
To:
Greetings,
Please see included note and Report from the Nova Scotia Affordable Housing
Commission. During the course of their work we participated in virtual
consultation exercises and made a submission to the Commission. We
highlighted the challenges of short-term rentals to affordable housing and
emphasized the importance of committing to Long Term residency in any of
their recommendations, funding and projects.
The Report and recommendations are highlighted in several news reports
today, such as CBC, the Halifax Examiner and others. Hopefully, in the days
to come, there will be some critical analysis of these important
recommendations. Please take a look and provide your perspective and
questions to the Affordable Housing Commission email/contact points noted
below or directly to your MLA and the Minister of Housing and
Infrastructure.
I have also provided a link to the Canadian Centre for Policy
Alternatives report , *"Keys to a Housing Secure Future of All Nova
Scotians"*, that was issued this past week as well. It provides an
in-depth perspective on the causes of the housing issue and how they might
be addressed.
https://www.policyalternatives.ca/sites/default/files/uploads/publications/…
In terms of our particular objectives, the Commission does makes reference
to Short-term rentals in Recommendation 15 on Rural and Non-urban Housing,
p.48, and urges government to consult with stakeholders on "concerns
related to conversion of rental stock to short-term rentals" to "ensure
both an adequate supply of accommodation for visitors and permanent housing
for local residents." However, this work is given a lower priority and
designated as a Long Term goal, for 2025-26.
While 'housing policy', in general, is not the purpose of our particular
project we are concerned with any efforts that would assist the increase in
affordable housing. As such, we offer some personal observations on the
Report and Recommendations of the Commission.
A number of the recommendations must come as a disappointment to those who
wanted the government to take more affirmative action on behalf of those
unable to find and afford suitable, affordable housing. One of the
consultants who spoke to the Commission, Steve Pomeroy from Carleton
University and long-time analyst and researcher on housing policy in
Canada, noted that Halifax actually has a large supply of housing and is
building more. However, for many people, this housing is beyond their
financial means. He recommended that the Commission look not only at
'supply' of housing but the 'rental costs' that have gone way beyond
average. Sadly, the Commission did not address Pomeroy's observations in
the Report or recommendations but did note that all rents for units built
after 2015 are 53% higher than average and many cannot afford "market
rents". Unfortunately, in our view, the Commission has decided not to act
on the 'rent' issue , which they see as a disincentive for developing more
housing. Instead, according to Recommendations 10-12, they would like the
government to provide funds for a small Community Housing Growth Fund,
"modernize" and raise the rents in Public Housing and "expand housing for
seniors and the vulnerable" by supporting non-traditional housing options
such as secondary suites, tiny houses, lane-way housing and more rooming
houses. (p43-.45) This exclusion of ordinary people from the on-going
housing boom, all around us, includes persons with a disability. According
to the Commission,
" It is also more cost-effective to create accessible units for people with
disabilities by renovating existing units than building new rental
housing." (p.42) How this squares with the mission of 'housing as a human
right', now and in the future, is not addressed.
Much of the responsibility for renovating, developing and building
affordable housing is turned over to the private sector. The
Recommendations highlight the need to provide municipalities, property
managers and developers and non-profit housing associations with
incentives, relaxed regulations around zoning and density, reduced fees and
property taxes , access to common land and continued use of rent
supplements (but not rent control). The Commission has also recommended an
"independent arm's length agency" that would manage the on-going assessment
of housing needs, handle financing and have the authority to partner on
housing projects, presumably away from the apparent interference of the
Minister or local MLA's. The present Commission, including several
property manager and developer representatives, have offered to serve as an
advisory group to this new agency, an offer one hopes will be resisted.
While the intent of the Commission to encourage the provision of affordable
housing is laudable and needs critical support it seems unfortunate that
the approach is status quo. The sector that has turned housing into a
commodity to the point that ordinary people cannot afford to rent is not
chastened or regulated but encouraged to continue. Let's hope and work
toward an alternative approach.
Bill Stewart
for Neighbours Speak Up
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Affordable Housing Commission <
affordablehousingcommission(a)novascotia.ca>
Date: Mon, May 31, 2021 at 1:25 PM
Subject: Affordable Housing Commission Presents Recommendations
To: Affordable Housing Commission <affordablehousingcommission(a)novascotia.ca
>
Hi everyone,
We are pleased to inform you that the Nova Scotia Affordable Housing
Commission has completed its mandate and released its findings and
recommendations to the Government of Nova Scotia. Our 61-page report
entitled *Charting a new course for affordable housing in Nova Scotia*
contains 17 recommendations and 60 meaningful actions, which have been
shaped in part by your valuable input.
Many of these recommendations could take some time to implement, which is
why we are calling on government to make an immediate financial commitment
of $25 million to begin addressing this crisis.
Download a copy of the Commission’s final report
<https://beta.novascotia.ca/documents/affordable-housing-report-spring-2021>
Our call to action is thoughtful, balanced, and is rooted in our belief
that everyone has a right to adequate housing, and that housing is a
critical sector of our economy and a social determinant of health.
As we have learned during the past six months, our current affordable
housing crisis is not the result of a single event, but rather the
consequences of systemic challenges that have been building for years.
Similarly, there is no simple solution and no silver bullet to this complex
problem that governments around the world have been grappling with.
The solution requires not only a significant financial investment by all
levels of government, but a strong cross-sectoral collaboration to break
down systemic barriers.
Nova Scotia’s housing market is going through unprecedented times, a
situation that has certainly been exacerbated by a global pandemic. Our
mandate was to identify meaningful and actionable solutions that would
allow the provincial government to take immediate action.
Our recommendations have been informed by public input, expert advice, and
a comprehensive review of best practices. More than 2,000 individuals
shared their stories, expertise, and ideas throughout an extensive public
consultation process. This included more than 1,200 survey respondents,
over 570 responses from the public via our website, and over 400
participants in virtual workshops and focus groups.
We want to thank you for taking the time to share your views and ideas in a
written submission.
We invite you to read the report and share your comments via:
• Web portal:
https://nsaffordablehousingcommission.ca/getinvolved/guest_book
• Email: affordablehousingcommission(a)novascotia.ca
We want to thank you for your participation and interest.
Ren Thomas and Eiryn Devereaux, co-chairs
--
You are receiving this email because you have expressed interest in being
updated regarding the
short-term rental issue. If you do not wish to receive further messages
please let us know.